Craig and Beth Dieter had driven to Copley from their home in Kentucky to work on the property dispute and were visiting the Johnsons when the shooting occurred, Eshelman said. In a parked car outside were 16-year-old Autumn and the unidentified girl.
All were fatally shot except for Beth Dieter; it was unclear how she escaped harm or where she was Monday. Becky Dieter, the gunman's girlfriend, was shot around the same time as she came out of their house next door, police said.